Eldan Goldenberg is a user on weirder.earth. You can follow them or interact with them if you have an account anywhere in the fediverse. If you don't, you can sign up here.
Eldan Goldenberg @eldang

I've always felt kind of meh about The Grateful Dead, as both performers and songwriters. Somehow neither loving nor hating them feels like a character flaw. But I _adore_ Norma Waterson's cover of Black Muddy River: whosampled.com/cover/516817/No [the rest of the album is great too, but this is the song on it that can get stuck in my head from hearing 5 seconds of someone else's version of the song, and one of those earworms I'm always happy to have]

· Web · 0 · 1

This is also one of those songs that's hard for me not obnoxiously sing along to when I have it in my headphones in a public place.

@eldang I like this cover a lot! and yeah, the Grateful Dead have always struck me as pretty okay musicians who just happened to come along at the right moment in history to converge with something that was really magical for a lot of people. I find that for most humans, the "greatest" music was the music they heard during a particularly impressionable and formative time of life, typically a time they feel nostalgia toward.

@twistylittlepassages I suppose there is some of that, but personally I find it much easier to understand the love for some of their peers than them. Like, I'm a big Zepellin & Bowie fan, and I get what makes Sabbath & the Rolling Stones great, but the Dead just don't much for me.

I definitely see that bias around. I think it's also why so many bands I loved as a teenager / college student have reformed now that my cohort has money. But so few of them are still good....

why do people love the Grateful Dead Show more

why do people love the Grateful Dead Show more